AI Logos vs. Designer Logos: Who Did It Better?

AI design tools are everywhere right now, and they can spit out logos in just a few seconds. But here’s the catch: logos are more than just symbols. Branding is about meaning, story, and strategy — and that’s where human designers bring something AI simply can’t.

AI Logos vs Designer Logos: Why Human Strategy Wins Every Time

Let’s break down three client projects and see how AI logos compared to designer-created ones.

The Stone Lotus Salon

The Brief:

• Hair salon offering a tranquil, elevated salon experience

• Open to color palettes and typography

• Natural, peaceful, and elegant aesthetic

• Wanted a lotus in the design

• Inspired by nature, balance, and Bali-style

  
  

AI Version: There’s nothing really wrong with this AI-generated logo… it’s just a little flat.

My Version: How I made this branding true to the client — something AI couldn’t do:

• A lotus symbol, designed with 3 central blooms, subtly representing the client’s family

• Custom “S” letterforms, shaped to echo the soft curves of lotus petals

• A center dot symbolizing balance, presence, and harmony

  
  

  

Andy’s Wild Rise

The Brief:

• Micro-bakery specializing in homemade sourdough products

• Minimal, natural, simple, and rustic aesthetic

• Avoid bright colors or overly decorative illustrations

• Wanted a wheat stalk incorporated

• Warm, earthy color palette

  
  

AI Version: Again, there’s nothing really wrong with this one… it’s just overdone. A quick Google search for ‘bakery logo’ and you’ll see the same cliché wheat stalk.

My Version: How I made this branding true to the client (beyond AI’s one-size-fits-all):

• A custom abstract wheat stalk illustration, hand-textured for a natural, homemade feel

• A rustic serif font that adds artisanal character

• A modified “y” for better balance and legibility

Just Pack and Go with Mary

The Brief:

• Travel agent helping couples and families plan memorable, budget-conscious trips

• Classic and southern inspired

• Professional but approachable

• Preferred fun fonts

• Wanted a suitcase included in the logo

  
  

AI Version: This AI logo… was not it. AI even spelled my client's last name wrong! On top of that, there was way too much going on — the design felt busy and didn’t flow.

My Version: How I made this branding true to the client (beyond AI’s guesswork):

• A border design that subtly nods to suitcase stitching and the perforated edge of an airline ticket

• Hand-drawn suitcases, created with varied brushes and stroke weights for a textured, vintage effect

• A roughened serif font to capture the charm of old-world print

  
  

  

The Takeaway

AI tools are powerful and can be helpful in many areas of business — but when it comes to your brand identity, strategy and human creativity matter most. The real difference in AI logos vs designer logos is depth: AI can generate something fast, but a designer creates with intention, meaning, and long-term vision for your business.

---

I’m Britt — a freelance designer helping small businesses build beautiful, thoughtful brands that reflect who they are. If you're dreaming of a fresh look for your business — whether you’re just opening your doors or rebranding after years in business, I’d love to chat. From custom logos to full-service brand identity design, I help small businesses build brands that reflect what makes them different (and totally unforgettable). Reach out to start your own branding project.